The Ishnala Supper Club, An Old Fashion Jam Packed Evening

The Ishnala Supper Club in Wisconsin Dells, WI is what the locals might call an “Old Fashion” good time.

This Supper Club on Mirror Lake in the Dells does not take reservations. However, there is plenty to see while you wait.

Hike through their beautiful-waterfront-scenery &/or enjoy a pre-dinner Old Fashion or glass of local wine (or 2)!

Wine-wise, enjoy The Ishnala red or white made only for Ishnala by the Wollersheim Winery.

Ishnala Supper Club in Wisconsin Dells, WI: Voted #1

Ishnala Supper Club has been voted as Wisconsin’s #1 Supper Club, despite not providing relish trays as part of their meals.

Never mind the missing relish tray… Look at these options…

Hit By an Iceberg an Iceberg on Mirror Lake, Wisconsin Dells, WI

That is… an Iceberg Wedge Salad to kick off the seemingly endless supply of food at The Ishnala Supper Club.

You may not want to enjoy it all in one sitting as there’s more food coming. Simply request a to-go box. Be sure to request some to-go silverware as well, especially if you’re not a local & are staying in a hotel.

Ishnala Supper Club, Their Scallops Are Like Butter

Well before the scallops arrive, the butter arrives to melt at its leisure…

…& your table mates enjoy the bread basket & accompanying supper club fancy cheese

Perhaps you’re nervous about committing to only scallops for your main course.

No worries… Simply order 2 ala carte…

The Bread Basket, Au Gratin Potatoes, & a Rack of Lamb

Finally, the main event… After the side salad & the bread basket, it arrives…

After requesting a to-go box for your enormous Iceberg Wedge Salad, you may as well request another one for any bread left over… & the fancy supper club cheese for additional dipping.

You will need room for the potato you choose. The Cheesy Au Gratins are recommended, but it’s your choice ~~ always.

Finally, when was the last time you attempted a Rack of Lamb? If your answer is never or you can’t remember, it’s time to get after it. When is the next time you will return to The Ishnala on Mirror Lake in the Dells?

Be sure to stop by notmyfirstday.com for more Wisconsin fun & some Minnesota Nice.